Options

A bit of a harsh mother?

1246789

Comments

  • Options
    the thing that bothers me abut the test
    and about people's perception in general
    is that, because a person has difficulty understanding social situations they will necesarily close down. My boys go in all guns blazing

    i can imagine them being jolly at a funeral, like Del boy and rodney trotter in the batman and robin suits

    boy3 did not understand the "i have trouble making friends" question

    "making friends is easy, i just have to be nice to them"
    he totally bypasses all the social niceties and walks straight up to people as if he has known them all his life
    he can then drop them just as quickly

    boy1 used to be the same
    he has learnt to be more cautious now

    but both are still at risk as they will talk to anyone, and assume that person to just want to be friends with them.
  • Options
    well, that'd be the stereotype - and runners who spend time on the internet on a running website - i'm sure we can all add an extra few points just for being here!

    BTW, never, ever tell a psychiatrist you are a long-distance runner, especially if you are female (blokes are 'allowed' to be into 'sport', so get a bit more leeway).
    One particularly memorable occasion had me telling the psychiatrist about Thames Meander:
    Psychiatrist: <horrified look> 'So... is that normal?!'
    Duck: 'Statistically, obviously not!'
  • Options
    38 (!)

    very interesting reading this thread :-)

    interesting that my job involves a lot of stuff that came up on the test, some of which i find easy, some which i struggle with.
  • Options
    Mrs FR scores a perfect 50

    Me - 10
  • Options
    I do think the average NT control score of 16.4 is a bit on the low side - don't think anyone i know has tested out below 25 (but then given my friends & family that's hardly surprising).

    You may also find the Neurotypicality test amusing :¬)
  • Options
    FR I am very surprised!
    weren't you a techie in a former life?
  • Options

    I think this is a typical example of someone posting a relatively innocuous, amusing news item and the thread then spinning out of control and becoming really and truly f***ing amazing.

    I've been lurking with nothing useful to say but just wanted to tell you how much I've learned and how fantastic this (whole) place really is.
  • Options
    am afraid i have just been using it as a

    "i am not bonkers am i?" thread

    talking about me me me
    as usual

    :-)
  • Options
    I scored 11.
    I have met Lurker's boys and love the frankness of the eldest and youngest. Youngest asked me why I was still here in the morning, after I had stayed over, he wasn't being at all rude, merely intrigued. When I explained it had been too late to get the train home the previous night he was quite happy.

    My neighbour has a son of now 4, who I and others perceive as being "not in the normal range", she is struggling to cope as her younger child is "normal". I think he is very like his successful, defence lawyer, father.
  • Options
    That In no way is meant to dismiss her middle son. I also have the proud honor of buying hen a game that they preferred over the Simpsons :-)
  • Options
    i didn't think you were dismissing him Beebs

    :-)

  • Options
    Good Lurks :-)

    I worry about Harry, he is very bright, has friends, becomes very focused and is generally described as being eccentric
  • Options
    and btw your police man bro is very sexy :-)
  • Options
    you haven't met him


    have you?

  • Options
    I have he came on his motorbike from London last time I stayed over , had planned to arrive the night I was using your spare bed!
  • Options
    so he did
    i remember now

  • Options
    Yes I was a techie in a former life DG, and the score does puzzle me aa well. I was brutally honest when I took it though.

    I dont think I've ever wished that Mrs could be like everyone else, but I have wished that she hadn't had to suffer like she has. Thats not suffering caused directly by the Autism you understand, but suffering caused by others because they don't or wont understand or make allowances. (and I don't include folks who act out of ignorance either - you sort of get immune to that).

    I think thats the nub of why I don't want to see a cure or an invitro test. The disability itself never killed anyone, its the way its handled that can cause so much damage. So I do wonder a little if the drive for a cure is driven more by society's inability to deal with a condition that makes it (society) feel uncomfortable, than a desire to alleviate suffering.
  • Options
    And if you want comedy concrete thinking quotes I have around 27 years worth to dispense.

    Favourite subjects being:-

    Free range eggs
    Fly fishing
    Omlettes
    Flying saucers
  • Options
    12
    bit surprised by that

    i agree this is a fascianting and eduational thread
  • Options
    Mmmmm

    22 for me - interesting Thanks IDG

    And I agree with mutters and the hat wearing hippo


    will be back to reread and rethink....
  • Options
    cure NTs now! :P
    FR I do wonder whether test results are due to spending so much time around Mrs that your 'normal' reference has shifted? I'm pretty average compared to my friends at uni (rather at lot of whom actually have a diagnosis of their own / a compsci degree, which seem to be much the same thing), but I know that going to see my Incredibly Girly Cousin & her friends over Christmas (she's doing Fashion Design at Manchester uni) we make me feel a complete social klutz.
    But anyway I wouldn't be surprised if you scored differently on a more implicit test.
  • Options
    hippo i'd also wonder if your scores have been affected by your job, where you have to learn lots of people skills? I know I've dropped a lot of points on that test since I first took it at 6th form - mostly down to having more practice interacting with people in all sorts of situations, and a bit of being able to apply stuff i've learnt doing a psychology degree.
    the AQ test is also autism-specific - being dyspraxic is a bit different, as social impairment is incidental, and motor & sensory aspects are more important. This is one reason PDD (pervasive developmental disorders) are really hard to diagnose - they are a bit like sets of interlocking Venn diagrams, and some particular groups of features commonly cluster together & this gets a label, but as awareness, diagnosis, & changing environment pick up more features then different clusters are picked up & different diagnoses given. From reading research literature I'm probably most accurately described as hyperlexic, but when I was small then that wasn't a set of symptoms anyone had noticed together enough to give it a name (still only seems to be diagnosed much separately in America), and it's a lot harder to diagnose in adults.
  • Options
    <HEALTH WARNING - given some of the stuff i've posted on here - I should point out that I'm only a psychology undergradate. To be qualified to diagnose or treat nything at all would require me to actually get a degree, then spend 6 years getting professionally qualified, and even then I'd be very well supervised for a good while. Some of the stuff I've posted is early research, and while it's mostly been peer-reviewed & published, it's still new work that may well be superseded, some of it is controversial, and there are other theories out there (some of which were obviously concocted after a really good party, but others might even be right) & you are only getting my inaccurate recollections & occasional wild imaginings anyway. If you actually want to know anything about anything, go & talk to a proper medical doctor / Chartered Psychologist or the like. They can often be contacted via GPs or School Nurses.>

    (My academic supervisor has been known to pop up on here very occasionally, although I'm fairly sure he doesn't know who I am yet *looks paranoid*).
  • Options
    IDG

    yes, i agree
    I can play the game without thinking about it now

  • Options
    well - i'd tend to give myself extra points for communication because i do actually seem to be quite good at it in some circumstances - working on a chronic psychosis ward, or with children with non-verbal autism, i actually seem to do quite well at picking things up - maybe 'cos i'm used to not quite being able to read people, maybe because i'm picking up the same environmental stimuli that most people don't spot (one particular time on a playscheme then i went into a room & turned a noisy fan off, & a child who'd been screamin g& unco-operative all day just stopped screaming & started running round happily - i couldn't understand why no-one else had noticed it), maybe because i'm good at just focusing on one person & not thinking about all the other bits that are going on.
    doesn't always translate very well to NTs though, but in some circumstances i can do quite well on picking up social communication. Have also learnt to 'act parts' very well too - if i know about what's expected, like in the shop, i can be very confident & good at social stuff, even if a lot of the time it's more-or-less like sticking lots of Lego bricks together to make the right sort of shape for phoning someone up about an order, or selling a bike.
  • Options
    Yes DG I think that my score is skewed somewhat by my closeness with Mrs FR. I guess I just spend so much time being NT for two so to speak.

    I also have to suppress a lot of emotions that are unhelpful in our relationship. Anger is the big one. She gets very upset if I'm angry, even though its not with her. So I have to switch that off. Grief is another one she can't deal with.

    I relate to the "Acting" bit big time. Mrs has a host of scenarios stored in her head for various social situations (getting the train, giving a lecture, going to the shop) and they just come out like a familiar old film. gets thrown if something isn't right, or something unexepected happens though. She gave a lecture to some schoolkids at half term, and at the end they applauded, which is something her regular students don't do. So she got really scared and didn't know how to react at all.

    Another social device that she's found useful is the "I'm sorry could you repeat that?" whenever someone says something ambiguous. No one minds repeating what they've said once, and the repetition nearly always involves some re-phrasing, which may make whats said clearer for her.

  • Options
    23 for me (as someone with a mixed humanities/numerical higher education, 4 years working in IT and then 5 in accountancy).

    I agree with Waaps - this thread has turned out to be amazing.
  • Options
    To return to the subject very briefly.

    Mrs and I often discuss how we manage to coexist. Well she found this advert on youtube and showed me it. It does describe how things are. There are often times when her mind is a closed book even to me, and then there's suddenly a revelation, a conjuction of such clarity that its almost painful. If I might be forgiven some sentimentality, these are moments when I see the true beauty that lies within.

    Anyway - watch the video - you'll see what I mean

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=rUFeCd5asMw
  • Options
    I've lurked on this thread since it began and just want to thank DG, Lurkio and FR for their insights - qualified or not, I've learnt a heck of a lot and a few "issues" within my family have kind of fallen in to place.

    Fascinating stuff.
  • Options
    Have just spent the last 15 mins reading it all too, only scored 9 on the test thing though, too damn sociable I guess, can defs relate to the labelling part earlier. I work in SEN Ed with naughty kids, which accounts for rather a lot of SEN I'm afraid.
    Without banging on, couldn't agree more, ther is an increasing tendency to label and pigeonhole in education as part of the whole inclusion thing, It gives non specialists ie mainstream teachers an excuse to justify a particular type of behaviour (ie Bad)as in Ohh he must have traits of ..... (fill in the gaps with 3/4 letter acronym of your choice).
Sign In or Register to comment.